CM1, CM2, CM3: Contribution Margin for D2C Brands, With a Worked ₹ Example

By Vishesh Khurana — Nov 12, 2026

Contribution margin is the number that tells a D2C founder whether selling one more order makes the business richer or poorer. Indian D2C operators and investors split it into three layers, CM1, CM2 and CM3, because each layer answers a different question and each one breaks for a different reason.

The short answer: CM1 = net revenue − COGS. CM2 = CM1 − fulfilment and payment costs. CM3 = CM2 − marketing. CM3 is what each order contributes towards your fixed costs (team, rent, software) and, eventually, profit. If CM3 is negative, growth makes the loss bigger, not smaller.

Start with net revenue, not Shopify sales

Every layer is a percentage of net revenue, so getting net revenue wrong breaks all three. Net revenue is the value of orders that were delivered and kept, excluding GST, after discounts. Three common mistakes inflate it: counting GST you collected (it belongs to the government), counting RTO orders that never reached the customer, and counting orders that were later returned for a refund. We walk through the full bridge in Shopify sales vs real revenue.

CM1: net revenue minus COGS

CM1 is your gross margin on what customers actually kept. COGS is the landed cost of the product: manufacturing or purchase price, inbound freight and any duties. It answers one question: is the product priced correctly against what it costs to make? If CM1 is weak, no amount of logistics or marketing optimisation will save the order.

Note what does not belong in COGS: outbound shipping, packaging, payment fees and ads. Putting them here makes CM1 look worse and CM2 look better than they are, and it hides which team owns the problem.

CM2: CM1 minus fulfilment and payment costs

CM2 subtracts every variable cost of getting an order to the customer and getting paid for it. In India that list is longer than most templates assume: forward shipping, packaging, reverse shipping on RTO (return to origin) orders, reverse shipping on customer returns, payment gateway fees on prepaid orders, and COD handling or remittance fees on cash-on-delivery orders.

CM2 is the operations layer. It is where RTO and COD show up, which is why two brands with identical CM1 can have very different CM2. A brand with high COD share and high RTO pays forward and reverse shipping on parcels that never produced revenue.

CM3: CM2 minus marketing

CM3 subtracts marketing spend: Meta and Google ads, influencer fees, affiliate commissions and any performance spend. It answers the growth question: does acquiring customers at your current efficiency make money on the first order? CM3 is the layer investors ask about first, because it decides whether more capital produces more profit or more burn.

Some brands split out a CM4 that subtracts customer retention costs or allocates a share of fixed costs. There is no single standard beyond CM3; if you use CM4, define it on the slide.

A worked example in ₹

Take an illustrative brand (these numbers are an example, not a benchmark): ₹1,200 average order value ex-GST after discounts, 2,000 orders shipped a month, 18% RTO, 5% customer returns, 55% COD, ₹420 COGS per order, ₹70 forward shipping, ₹70 reverse shipping, ₹30 packaging, a 2% payment gateway fee, a ₹40 COD fee per delivered COD order, and ₹6 lakh of monthly marketing.

Orders. 18% of 2,000 is 360 RTO orders, so 1,640 are delivered. 5% of those, 82 orders, are returned, so 1,558 orders are kept.

Net revenue. 1,558 × ₹1,200 = ₹18.70 lakh. Note that this is 22% below the ₹24 lakh of ex-GST value shipped, before anyone has spent a rupee on logistics.

CM1. COGS on kept orders is 1,558 × ₹420 = ₹6.54 lakh. CM1 = ₹18.70 lakh − ₹6.54 lakh = ₹12.15 lakh, or 65.0% of net revenue. (RTO and returned stock is assumed to go back on the shelf; if returns arrive damaged, CM1 is lower.)

CM2. Fulfilment: every shipped order pays ₹100 for forward shipping and packaging (₹2.00 lakh), and 442 RTO and returned parcels pay ₹70 of reverse shipping (₹30,940), for ₹2.31 lakh in total. Payment costs: 2% on 900 prepaid orders is ₹21,600, and ₹40 on 902 delivered COD orders is ₹36,080, for ₹57,680. CM2 = ₹12.15 lakh − ₹2.31 lakh − ₹0.58 lakh = ₹9.27 lakh, or 49.6%.

CM3. CM2 − ₹6 lakh of marketing = ₹3.27 lakh, or 17.5% of net revenue — about ₹199 per delivered order.

Whether ₹3.27 lakh is good depends entirely on fixed costs. If the team, rent and tools cost ₹9 lakh a month, this brand burns about ₹5.7 lakh a month despite a healthy-looking CM1, and CM3 is the number that shows it. You can reproduce every figure above, and change any input, in the free D2C contribution margin calculator.

Per order or per month?

Report both. Per-month CM3 tells you how much of fixed cost you cover. Per-order CM3 (we divide by delivered orders) tells you what one more order is worth, which is the number to compare against CAC. Be explicit about the denominator: per shipped, per delivered and per kept order give three different answers from the same data.

The four mistakes that flatter contribution margin

Using GST-inclusive revenue. On an 18% GST product, a ₹1,416 checkout total is ₹1,200 of revenue. Revenue taken from the larger number is overstated by 18%, and every margin built on it is wrong.

Ignoring RTO in fulfilment. An RTO parcel pays forward shipping, packaging and reverse shipping and earns nothing. Many templates only cost shipping on delivered orders.

Using platform-attributed revenue for CM3. Marketing belongs against net revenue from every channel, not the revenue Meta claims. See MER vs ROAS.

Averaging across SKUs. A blended CM3 can hide a hero SKU that funds three loss-making ones. Once the blended number is right, compute it per category.

What to do with the number

Fix the layers in order. A CM1 problem is pricing or sourcing. A CM2 problem is usually RTO, COD and shipping rates. A CM3 problem is marketing efficiency, and it is the one most often blamed for problems that actually live in CM2. Then turn CM3 into runway: monthly CM3 minus fixed costs is your operating burn, which is the input to the free runway calculator. For a brand that carries stock, inventory changes that answer; we cover that in runway for a D2C brand with inventory.

FounderConsole is built to keep these numbers current from your own data instead of a spreadsheet rebuilt every month, and it has a free plan with no credit card required. Start free when the spreadsheet stops being worth maintaining.

Cite FounderConsole

Writing about runway, burn or fundraising? FounderConsole publishes the figures and formulas it uses so they can be quoted directly. Attribute them to FounderConsole and link https://founderconsole.ai.